The tradition of wearing an artificial red poppy to commemorate soldiers who have died in wartime has existed since 1920 and was inspired by the famous poem ‘In Flanders Field’. The poppy has become an increasingly political symbol in recent years and is especially prominent in the UK where just about every media outlet, political party and sporting occasion promotes its use. So widespread has the use of the poppy become that to not wear one is subtly viewed as somehow being unpatriotic or unwilling to acknowledge the sacrifice of soldiers. Channel 4 television presenter Jon Snow famously labelled the compulsion to wear the poppy as ‘poppy fascism’.
The political correctness surrounding the tradition is so advanced and has accelerated so much in recent years that politicians especially seem to compete with each other to be seen to wear the poppy first. Consequently an event that was intended to raise funds for charity has become an annual photo opportunity in the lead up to November 11th, Armistice day.
The tradition has always caused problems in Ireland and Ulster where the British military are reviled by the Catholic population for their part in ‘The Troubles’ and especially for ‘Bloody Sunday’. In Ulster the poppy is seen as a distinct symbol of Britishness and is used almost exclusively by the Unionist community there.
The quandary for the Irish is that so many of their relatives served in the British army and served in the first world war with distinction. Given that the initial purpose of the wearing of the poppy was to recognise the sacrifice of those who died in the first world war it can be difficult to refuse what has become an increasing pressure to conform.
Not everyone does conform though. Irish soccer player James McClean of Sunderland refused to wear a poppy in a November 2012 Premiership match against Everton. The high-profile event was televised worldwide and regardless of a persons view on the matter it has to be admitted that it took a lot of courage for the 23-year-old McClean not to be bullied into submission. Irish Taoiseach Enda Kenny also did not wear a poppy when attending a Remembrance Sunday service in Enniskillen on the same weekend.
What is clear now is that what was intended as an exercise in charity has been taken over by the political and media establishment to the extent that it deeply corrupted. While everyone should be able to celebrate their heritage and history the freedoms that the men and women of the first world war fought for are not at all well served by this turn of events.
14 thoughts on “Remembrance day poppys – a quandary for the Irish and Ireland”
I thought that this was to commemorate WW1 – how has it been hijacked by the politicians?
Someone should start a campaign to have green poppies
It is sometimes lost in the arguments that most soldiers who have died in wartime were paid to do a job. The term Conscription in the United Kingdom has existed for two periods with the first from 1916 to 1919. The first time, The Military Service Act 1916 (27 January 1916) was passed by UK government was on 2nd March 1916 which imposed conscription on all British single men aged 18 to 41 except those in essential wartime occupations, the medically unfit, religious ministers and conscientious objectors.
Due to political considerations, the Act did not extend to Ireland, which was then part of the United Kingdom. Many Irish volunteered and were left stranded and many cases in unmarked graves. The Poppy charity did not make any distinction between volunteers and conscripted soldiers.
Its shamefulness that political figureheads claim their allegiance not to those who are dead but the hereditary hypocrites who try to justify forceful coercion, when in 1846 the political figureheads then would not feed their citizens during a biological war / national emergency.
No poppies symbols in the fields of rotten potatoes, where are the charitable acts to erect the graves stones of all those braves who lost their fight against an Empire and a epidemic easily solved with state support?
More British force personnel were employed in Ireland alone to protect the food transport out of Ireland during the “Famine” period than the numbers Britain sent to Falklands or Iraq. Over one million Irish died of starvation then at a consequence of UK government policy.
There needs to be a more appropriate remembrance. The Poppy does not determine which soil is owned by monarch, dictator or country before it grows. It also does not care who owns the land when it dies either.
I believe there should be a day of remembrance for those who died in the Irish Famine and the wearing of a green poppy would be a great symbol. The monies raised could go towards an educational fund, such as the Jews have for their ‘Never Again’ policy.
That is a very good idea. I would support that as many diaspora would.
It seems that the significance of the poppy has been blurred, especially to the majority that were born after the first world war.
There SHOULD be something to commemorate those that served their countries military with great risk to life and limb with a national day of recognition and thanks!
I’ve seen a symbol depicting a broken rifle that would fit!
I really enjoy getting your newsletter every month. Thank you for sharing it with me. I resend to friends. Thanks and God Bless
Its very appropriate that there should be a Remembrance Day for those that died in the Great Famine and all other famines that occurred in Ireland.
While the British glorify war, they forget the innocent victims of their misrule in Ireland whose only options were to try and survive famine or emigrate.
Wearing green poppies would be a fitting tribute as would be a Famine Remembrance Day held annually
Will someone please explain Great Britain to me? The Brits native to the island were the Welsh and Cornish, both of whom were continually scorned by the English (which is to say, German) conquerors. Call it by its rightful name, England, and forever banish the term Great Britain or the United Kingdom. There is nothing “great” about contemporary England, a servile little island paying homage to a monarchy they continually had to import. The English “Empire” is a joke. It left millions of innocent dead around the globe because of venal politicians who lined their own pockets.
God, what a pitiable country, still mired in the 19th century!
What a perceptive insight into the reality of Britain today Its a pity the politicians cant get out of their ivory towers and live in the real world of the people whose lives are manipulated in the name of ‘Great’ Britain The empire is gone and reality has not yet penetrated their imperialist minds. But in the Brexit issue Ireland has a trump card – the border. It may yet be a dominant Ireland with favors being sought by its island neighbor in their new impoverished state.
With reference to Brexit I think it will be the Irish that suffer more than the brits. We need to take the chip off our shoulders and work with them. We have more in common with them and Than any other nation
my wife and I live in Canada shees English and I’m born and bred irish.on reading all your coments some more pointed than others ,my conclusion is your all right….
It off and hink you are right,but I know England is making a huge mistake by leaving the E U. There will be no easy route for trade with Europe after brexit. Europeans are p—d off at England especially France and Germany and I think they will retaliate. E verybody thinks that Ireland will suffer ,but what about companies in England who may not be able to trade with Europe after the breakup. Ireland has to stick with England ,its biggest trading partner but Ireland will not leave Europe. A resurgence of the commonwealth , .Idont know.
I think if we all looked at our heritage we would get a shock.My mother was Irish as her nine siblings were,my Grandmother was a McMahon my Grandfather’s Ancestors were originally from Scotland and before that Scandinavia.So some of us are a Mishmash.If we all look at our humanity and not at our race the world would be a better place.If you only wear the poppy for Micheal Lehane,now there was a hero .I some times think of the tears we bring to God’s Eyes and why he doesn’t clean the board and be done with us.,Oh by the way my grandfather was a National Teacher,he had a farm in Aghabog,he made no distinction when giving to the poor . Maria Cunningham.(god bless and keep you and make his face to shine upon you)